PENSIONS
See geographic subdivisions, below.
See also EMPLOYMENT, especially for same-sex benefits which are not pension
benefits
PENSIONS -- ALBERTA
Suing the government [Robert Lawrence is suing his employer, the Government of
Alberta, over pension benefits; he wants his 22-year partner to get pension
benefits when he dies; details, including comment by David Hancock, justice
minister].
P153 (v20n4)(June 5, 2002): 14 (19cm.)
PENSIONS -- BRITISH COLUMBIA
Scrooge at work in BC legislature [John Cameron, who has AIDS, fighting in court over
provincial right of deduction of federal pension disability benefits from provincial
disability benefits].
P111 (v15n2)(March 12, 1997): 23 (13cm.)
BC grants benefits ["British Columbia government has become the first government
to grant pension benefits to same-sex couples without having to be taken to
court"; reactions; other details].
P122 (v16n5)(July 29, 1998): 26 (25cm.)
PENSIONS -- CANADA
Gay pensioners to fight Ottawa [Jim Egan; government pension benefits].
P37 (Dec. 1, 1987): 10 (26cm.)
Charter challenge [lawyer for James Egan and John Nesbit will apply for support to
Court Challenges Program in challenge of Old Age Security Act; request
for written support from community to Program for this application].
P42 (June 29, 1988): 7 (27cm.)
Gay couple fights back [James Egan and John Nesbit, of Courtenay, B.C.; Court
Challenges Program announced will provide funds to launch case re spouses'
allowance under Old Age Security Act]. From Ottawa Citizen.
P44 (Sept. 21, 1988): 24 (28cm.)
40 years of love & activism [James (Jim) Egan and John (Jack) Nesbit -- biographical
details and information about their legal challenge regarding pension
discrimination in the Old Age Security Act; booklet, Jim Egan, Canada's
Pioneer Gay Activist, now available]. By Harry Hill; reprinted from Angles.
P45 (Nov. 9, 1988): 4-6 (97cm.)
Not traditional couple [Jim Egan and John Nesbit case regarding refusal of federal
government to grant spousal allowance to Egan's 40-year lover after Egan turned
65; Federal Court judge, Leonard Martin, refused request; decision will be
appealed].
P69 (v9n8)[misnumbered on cover as v9n7](Dec. 18, 1991): 17 (34cm.)
No Old Age Pension [Federal Court of Appeal ruled April 29, 1993 that same-sex
couples not entitled to old age pension benefits; 2 to 1 split decision on appeal
by James Egan and John Nesbit].
P81 (v11n4)(June 9, 1993): 20-21 (27cm.)
Going to Supreme Court [Supreme Court of Canada agrees to hear appeal on spousal
pension issue of James Egan and Jack Nesbit; two lower courts have ruled
against; Supreme Court expected to hear case next year].
P85 (v11n8)(Dec. 8, 1993): 21 (11cm.)
Senior couple challenges Charter [case is now considered by Supreme Court of Canada;
"benefit in question is a spousal allowance paid to a pensioner's spouse when that
spouse is between 60 and 65 and the couple has a low income; large number of
named religious groups -- Christian (Roman Catholic and fundamentalist),
Islamic, Sikh, Hindu -- argue against gay couple; additional details].
P93 (v12n8)(Dec. 7, 1994): 21 (45cm.)
A mixed decision [Supreme Court of Canada issues mixed decision in case brought by
James Egan and Jack Nesbit; ruled 9 to 0 that gays/lesbians protected against
discrimination by Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms; pension benefits
issue rejected 5 to 4].
P97 (v13n4)(June 7, 1995): 19 (48cm.)
Courting feds for benefits [still "uneven array of rulings and decisions from both the
courts and various human rights tribunals"; article is on same-sex pension
benefits and also about broader same-sex benefits; table titled "Status of Benefits
Across Canada" accompanies article].
P108 (v14n7)(Oct. 23, 1996): 20 (63cm.)
Marriage & taxes [MP Svend Robinson has introduced two private member's bills --
C-385 is "designed to allow same-sex partners to have a legally recognized
marriage"; C-386 "would amend the Income Tax Act and the Canada Pension
Plan Act's definition of spouse"; private member's bills seldom become law].
P121 (v16n4)(June 10, 1998): 24 (27cm.)
Court affirms pension rights [panel of Ontario Court of Appeal judges rules that
definition of spouse in Income Tax Act is unconstitutional because of
exclusion of gays/lesbians; background and details].
P121 (v16n4)(June 10, 1998): 25 (20cm.)
Reform wants courts ignored [Reform Party MPs call on federal government to appeal
April 23 Ontario Court of Appeal ruling in case filed by Nancy Rosenberg and
CUPE, a ruling which stated that Income Tax Act discriminated with regard to
pension plan survivor benefits for same-gender couples; many details and names].
P122 (v16n5)(July 29, 1998): 27 (39cm.)
Not separate but equal [newsnote that Federal Court judge, Andrew MacKay, says
Ottawa cannot create "separate but equal" benefits plan for lesbians/gays;
must integrate pension plans of same-gender couples into existing program; etc.].
P123 (v16n6)(Sept. 16, 1998): 23 (18cm.)
Suing the government [class-action suit against federal government alleging
discrimination for denial of survivor benefits under Canada Pension Plan;
Saskatoon "queer and AIDS activist," Brent Daum, has joined with others in
the suit; details].
P149 (v19n8)(Dec. 5, 2001): 10 (25cm.)
Pension suit pending ["class action suit on behalf of surviving gay and lesbian
spouses who were denied Canada Pension Plan benefits" was registered
Nov. 27, 2001; set to go to trial Sept. 8, 2003 in Ontario Superior Court
of Justice; concerns those whose same-sex common-law partner died
between April 17, 1985 and Jan. 1, 1998; other details].
P163 (v21n6)(Sept. 10, 2003): 26 (21cm.)
Surviving spouses go to trial [class action lawsuit against federal government
regarding pre-1998 Canada Pension Plan benefits for surviving gay
spouses went to trial Sept. 8/03; "decision not expected until early
next year"; details].
P164 (v21n7)(Oct. 22, 2003): 24 (13cm.)
Court gives, Martin takes [newsnote that Paul Martin government has decided
to appeal ruling of Ontario Superior Court that federal government
discriminated against surviving partners in same-sex relationships in not
making Canada Pension Plan survivor benefits retroactive to 1985; some
details].
P166 (v22n1)(Jan. 28, 2004): 26 (15cm.)
Survivor victory [class-action lawsuit for Canada Pension Plan survivor benefits
retroactive to 1985 has been settled; claimants happy, but government
could appeal; details].
P173 (v22n8)(Dec. 8, 2004): 27 (26cm.)
PENSIONS -- NOVA SCOTIA
Nova Scotia backs down [following Ontario ruling that a portion of Income Tax Act
unconstitutional in not recognizing same-sex couples; Nova Scotia had been
fighting against paying survivor pension benefits to Wilson Hodder and to
Paul Boulais; other details].
P121 (v16n4)(June 10, 1998): 26 (20cm.)
PENSIONS -- ONTARIO
Battling for benefits [James Rawson, partner of the late Rev. James McCue, Anglican
priest, takes Anglican Diocese of Toronto to Ontario Human Rights Commission
for denial of survivor pension benefits; details given].
P90 (v12n5)(July 27, 1994): 20 (35cm.)
Pension plan case lost [Canadian Union of Public Employees decides to appeal recent
Ontario Court General Division decision rejecting request to open pension plan to
same-sex couples; elaboration and comments, including apparent relationship to
Egan-Nesbit legal case].
P100 (v13n7)(Oct. 25, 1995): 22 (28cm.)
Spousal win [municipal governments in Ontario now must provide dental and health
coverage for same-sex spouses of employees; pension plan is overseen
by federal Income Tax Act].
P110 (v15n1)(Jan. 29, 1997): 25 (16cm.)
Another step [newsnote that Ontario court rules "that pension plans in Ontario must
offer same-gender pension benefits"; ruling Dec. 8/98; case "follows up a
1992 Ontario Human Rights Tribunal ruling"].
P126 (v17n1)(Jan. 27, 1999): 25 (16cm.)